I think the most troubling part of what I am talking about is the discussion on reform. We as educators know that no two students, families, schools or communities are the same. A standardized approach to educating our children is not going to work. Continually testing such a narrow part of what is important in our curriculum is not going to make our system stronger. We know that poverty is a huge factor in why some students do not meet expectations across this country. We also know that the majority of teachers in this country are dedicated professionals that care about students and their growth. People working in American classrooms know that the current charter school movement, merit pay schemes, and the dissolution of teachers unions are not going to make our schools magically produce results that put us on top of the international NAEP results. The folks who are in control of the edreform movement do not care what we say because we are gaining no traction by telling the world they are wrong and we are right! We have to be willing to talk about solutions to the problems that do exist. We have to talk about our successes and frame them in the context of how our students are learning and growing. We have to show how what we do in all areas of education (outside of math and reading) will allow our students to become competent citizens and participants in our diverse economy. The next time John Stewart asks a prominent education advocate what our plan is to make sure our students have the best education we can offer, the answer has to be something other than the other side is wrong.
The Ultimate Hypocrite: Edublog Award Thoughts.....
The only thing I really dislike about the Edublog Awards is what I am doing right now - talking about their worth in the terms of what I like or dislike about them. Awards are awards. People like to get them, deserved or not. Some people dislike awards. That is their right. I am not sure why we have to spend any energy at all debating this ad-nauseum.....every year. If you want an award, write well and often, participate a lot, and network. If you don't like the award "season" in this circle, ignore it or avoid it. Spend the time you use lamenting about them making Christmas cookies, smiling, and otherwise spreading good cheer....or not! We all certainly have the right to disagree with things, but I think this argument is just rather trivial. There, that is off my chest. Now I am going to do my best to smile and otherwise spread good cheer.